How To Mediate Away An Insurance Claim

In today’s discussion, we delve into a real-life case that exemplifies the transformative impact of mediation, showcasing how it can spare parties from the burdens of litigation while ensuring fair outcomes. The scenario revolves around a vehicle damage incident and the intricacies of insurance coverage.

The Setting: Commercial Auto Insurance and Policy Cancellation
The case involves a business with a commercial auto insurance policy covering a fleet of vehicles used for local operations. Despite having full coverage for five years, the company faced a setback when they failed to pay the premium at the policy renewal’s end. This led to the cancellation of their coverage, setting the stage for a collision and subsequent claim.

The Unraveling: A Two-Hundred-Thousand-Dollar Claim and Policy Cancellation
A collision occurred, resulting in damages exceeding $200,000, encompassing vehicle damage and injuries. When the company filed a claim, the insurance company contested, pointing out the policy cancellation due to non-payment. This prompted the company to sue both the insurer and the insurance agent, citing a lack of payment reminders as a key contention.

Legal Dilemma: The Path to Litigation and the Role of Mediation
The case was headed for litigation, a situation where both parties, particularly the insurance company, preferred mediation. This preference stemmed from the insurer’s errors and omissions (E&O) coverage, safeguarding against potential mistakes. Mediation was seen as a way to assess risks and explore a resolution before heading to court.

Mediation in Action: Unveiling Perspectives and Common Ground
During the mediation process, all involved parties, including the insurance carrier, the E&O company, the insurance broker, and the injured parties, participated in discussions. The focus shifted from legal battles to understanding losses, risks, and common ground. The mediator emphasized that once a case enters litigation, control diminishes and uncertainties abound.

Revealing Priorities: The True Intentions of the Injured Parties
Insights gained during mediation revealed that the injured parties were primarily concerned with avoiding financial losses. Without uninsured motorist coverage, they faced medical bills, lost wages, and vehicle damage expenses. The monetary component of their claim was significantly lower than initially estimated.

Unraveling Responsibilities: Evaluating the Insurance Broker’s Actions
The insurance broker’s role was examined, leading to an exploration of industry best practices. It was discovered that the practice of reminding clients to pay premiums wasn’t universal and could set unfavorable precedents. The broker’s contribution to the chain of events was acknowledged, raising questions about retention practices for non-paying customers.

Shared Consequences: A Balanced Resolution
Ultimately, a balanced resolution emerged through mediation. The injured parties received compensation, the insurance broker and company shared financial responsibility, and the insurance carrier contributed while learning lessons about client retention. The outcome showcased the mediation’s ability to turn a potentially catastrophic scenario into a manageable and fair solution.

Reflections: Lessons Learned and Mutual Understanding
The resolution, while not without losses, left all parties content with the outcome. The company, even with the total loss of a vehicle, recognized the value of the lessons learned. The mediation process demonstrated that the consequences each party faced were proportionate to their contribution to the situation.

Conclusion: The Mediator’s Vision and the Power of Collaborative Solutions
In the end, this case serves as a testament to the power of mediation, where the mediator’s role is not to force solutions but to unveil the already existing common ground. It highlights how collaboration can turn what could be a contentious legal battle into a win-win for all parties involved. Mediation, as a method, stands out as a tool for managing risks and finding resolutions that benefit everyone. For further assistance or insights into mediation, visit our website at

Watch our YouTube video:

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top